Independent. Not affiliated with YVAS or the City.

Sources

Every claim on this site traces to a source below. Primary sources are City records. News and party statements are marked unverified.

How we decide verdicts

  • Verdicts (keep, vote out, undecided) are opinion. They are our judgment, based on documented votes and statements.
  • We show the votes behind each verdict next to it. A member gets a keep or vote-out verdict only after we can cite their votes. Until then they are undecided.
  • Items we could not confirm are labeled. Staff proposals and committee decisions are not Council votes.
  • The City's minutes list who was present and name only members who voted no, abstained or were absent. A yes recorded as part of a unanimous vote means the member was present and not named as a dissenter.
  • No shelter, city staff member or council member reviewed or approved this site. It is an independent effort and is not affiliated with YVAS, the City of Billings, any party or any candidate.
  • Work session voice votes are direction to staff, not formal votes, and have no roll call.

Source list

  1. YVAS social graphic: no longer accepting strays from city limits

    YVAS | 2026-11 | Statement Verified

    https://yvas.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/strays.png
    Image posted on yvas.org. A party to the dispute, so treat as that party's account.

  2. Billings City Council Members (official roster, all-council email)

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/159/City-Council-Members

  3. Draft minutes, City Council regular meeting, September 14, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-09-14 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CC/20260914_2032/2047_09142026DraftMinutes.pdf
    Roll call, meeting time and place, and public comment rules.

  4. Council meeting schedule (2nd and 4th Mondays), City FAQ

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/Faq.aspx?QID=372

  5. City Council and City Clerk contacts

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/142/City-Council

  6. Billings City Charter (council structure, wards, terms, mayor's vote)

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/151/City-Charter

  7. Official city ward map (PDF)

    City of Billings | 2025-12 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/DocumentCenter/View/54411/CityWardsSmall-12-2025
    Link verified on the city members page. We have not read the map contents.

  8. Yellowstone County Elections

    Yellowstone County | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.yellowstonecountymt.gov/elections/

  9. Montana voter information: check your registration and polling place

    State of Montana | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://app.mt.gov/voterinfo/

  10. City directory page: Mike Nelson

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=386
    Source for term and contact details.

  11. City directory page: Kendra Shaw

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=2
    Source for term and contact details.

  12. City directory page: Mark Nicholson

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=3
    Source for term and contact details.

  13. City directory page: Roy Neese

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=5
    Source for term and contact details.

  14. City directory page: Denis Pitman

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=387
    Source for term and contact details.

  15. City directory page: Bill Kennedy

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=518
    Source for term and contact details.

  16. City directory page: Amy Aguirre

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=388
    Source for term and contact details.

  17. City directory page: Scott Aspenlieder

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=517
    Source for term and contact details.

  18. City directory page: Andrew Lindley

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=389
    Source for term and contact details.

  19. City directory page: Mike Boyett

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=10
    Source for term and contact details.

  20. City directory page: Tony O'Donnell

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/directory.aspx?EID=11
    Source for term and contact details.

  21. YVAS: Announcing a difficult sheltering decision (Nov 5, 2026)

    YVAS | 2026-11-05 | Statement Unverified

    https://yvas.org/announcing-a-difficult-sheltering-decision/
    A party's statement. Not independently confirmed.

  22. YVAS: The end of an 18-year partnership (Jun 30, 2026)

    YVAS | 2026-06-30 | Statement Unverified

    https://yvas.org/end-of-an-18-year-partnership/
    A party's account. The City's account differs on cost and who declined what.

  23. City Council agenda packet, Nov 23, 2026 (revised 11/19/2026), Item 3

    City of Billings | 2026-11-19 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CC/20261123_2037/AGENDApacket_11-23-26_0111_2052.pdf
    Item 3 terms, staff report, planned roll call, July negotiation statement.

  24. Work session summary, Nov 2, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-11-02 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CCWS/20261102_2026/2041_11022026WSSummary.pdf
    Four directions to staff, passed by voice vote.

  25. Work session summary, Sep 21, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-09-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CCWS/20260921_2023/2038_09212026WSSummary.pdf

  26. Work session summary, Jul 6, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-07-06 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CCWS/20260706_2018/2033_07062026WSSummary.pdf
    Contract expiry and City takeover of shelter operations.

  27. Minutes, City Council, Jul 27, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-07-27 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CC/20260727_2003/2018_07272026Minutes.pdf
    Read from scanned minutes; PDF confirmation pending.

  28. Minutes, City Council, Sep 28, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-09-28 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CC/20260928_2033/2048_09282026Minutes.pdf
    Read from scanned minutes; PDF confirmation pending.

  29. Minutes, City Council, Oct 12, 2026

    City of Billings | 2026-10-12 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2026/CC/20261012_2034/2049_10122026Minutes.pdf
    Read from scanned minutes; PDF confirmation pending.

  30. Draft minutes, City Council, Nov 24, 2025

    City of Billings | 2025-11-24 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2025/CC/20251124_1842/1857_11242025DRAFTMinutes.pdf
    Marked DRAFT by the City.

  31. Minutes, City Council, Feb 12, 2024

    City of Billings | 2024-02-12 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2024/CC/20240212_1645/1660_02122024Minutes.pdf
    Read from scanned minutes; PDF confirmation pending.

  32. Minutes, City Council, Mar 24, 2025

    City of Billings | 2025-03-24 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2025/CC/20250324_1782/1797_03242025Minutes.pdf
    Read from scanned minutes; PDF confirmation pending.

  33. Work session summary, Sep 15, 2025 (smoke incident update)

    City of Billings | 2025-09-15 | Primary record Verified

    https://public.destinyhosted.com/bilmtdocs/2025/CCWS/20250915_1849/1864_09152025WSSummaryAI.pdf

  34. KTVQ: Yellowstone Valley Animal Shelter will stop taking in strays and lost animals

    KTVQ | 2026-11 | News report Unverified

    https://www.ktvq.com/news/yellowstone-valley-animal-shelter-will-stop-taking-in-strays-and-lost-animals
    News report. Source of the Lindley quote.

  35. KULR: Yellowstone Valley Animal Shelter stops accepting Billings animals due to contract dispute

    KULR | 2026-11-05 | News report Unverified

    https://www.kulr8.com/news/yellowstone-valley-animal-shelter-stops-accepting-billings-animals-due-to-contract-dispute/article_34bc64f0-c921-4340-b7eb-b178ddc96cbe.html
    News report.

  36. City page listing agendas and minutes

    City of Billings | Accessed 2026-11-21 | Primary record Verified

    https://www.billingsmt.gov/117/Agendas-Minutes

  37. Community 7 TV video, Nov 2, 2026 work session

    Community 7 TV | 2026-11-02 | Primary record Verified

    https://cloud.castus.tv/vod/comm7tv/video/6ae94cc9f46c0e00024ba8ca?page=HOME
    Video. We have not watched it. It is where individual voice votes can be seen.

  38. City of Billings Purchasing email to RFP respondents, 'Animal Shelter Operations RFP' (Nov 4, 2026)

    City of Billings Purchasing Agent | 2026-11-04 | Copy of a City record (provided to us by a recipient) Unverified

    Not hosted on this site.
    Provenance: a screenshot of the email as received by a proposer, provided to us. Not hosted here. Names no provider.

  39. YVAS Facebook post, Nov 20, 2026, 4:46 PM (no link captured)

    YVAS (Facebook page) | 2026-11-20 | Statement Unverified

    Not hosted on this site.
    YVAS statement (party to the dispute). Cited by page and date. Says YVAS learned the City intends to move forward with another provider, and that it cannot afford to subsidize a month-to-month transition at its own expense.

  40. YVAS: Statement to our community

    YVAS | 2026-11 | Statement Unverified

    https://yvas.org/statement-to-our-community/
    YVAS statement (party to the dispute). Listed as the Executive Director statement in YVAS communications. We have not independently confirmed its contents.

Known gaps

What we could not confirm or have not checked yet.

  • We found no explanation from any individual member of their vote on the YVAS contract itself in a primary source.
  • Individual voice votes at the Jul 6 and Nov 2, 2026 work sessions are only visible on Community 7 video, which we have not watched.
  • Several sets of minutes (Feb 12, 2024; Mar 24, 2025; Jul 27, Sep 28 and Oct 12, 2026) were image scans that we read with text recognition. Names and tallies are marked for confirmation against the PDF images.
  • The Nov 24, 2025 minutes are marked DRAFT by the City.
  • We could not read several paywalled or blocked news articles, so they are not used here.

Corrections

If we got a vote wrong, tell us and we will fix it and say so. Send the correction and, if you can, a link to the record.

corrections@billingspetvotes.org